Posted: Thu May 29, 2008 5:16 am Post subject: Desktop Software CI's
Is each install of the Software on desktop is separate CI? If so if we have 10,000 desktop we will have 10,000 software CI's associated with it. Is the companies do this or have one software CI and have a relationship with 10,000 desktop?
1 CI except as John says if you need to manage licenses. You could also count the number of relationships made to the software CI. Make a rule that if software is installed then a relationship is made. However in practice this is is cumbersome and using a CMDB like this for managing software licenses is not ideal - I have yet to see an out of box CMDB that actually does meaningfull software licensing.
Desktop inventory tools - the ones that sweep the network and report back installed applications are better at this (though limitations may exist in scanning some subnets / DMZ's) and can be linked to a CMDB. _________________ Mark O'Loughlin
ITSM / ITIL Consultant
Joined: Mar 31, 2008 Posts: 109 Location: North West England
Posted: Thu May 29, 2008 7:56 pm Post subject:
Further to my original point, we are also planning to use the CMDB for software licensing by having a CI type of license. So, for example, the desktop 123 CI, would be linked to the single Firefox software CI, which in turn is linked to the single Mozilla public license CI.
This was the only way we could think of managing the 100's of different types of license. Having one software CI covering each licensed product works in some circumstances but falls down when you have a floating license because you are recording installations not licenses. By having the license CI, we can record the number licneses we hold as an attribute, whether it's site, node locked, or floating.
We also have a federated CMDB, which allows us to scan the desktops and link PCs to software in our CMDB. Without it, we'd have nightmare job. _________________ Mick Smith
Change, Configuration and Release Manager
A CI for license is what I meant but may not have actually said that ... anyway ...
"We also have a federated CMDB, which allows us to scan the desktops and link PCs to software in our CMDB. Without it, we'd have nightmare job."
--- will this setup autoamtically update the CI to the License CI once it detects an install? To try and manually track license usage is an admin nightmare _________________ Mark O'Loughlin
ITSM / ITIL Consultant
What I am trying to do is solve two cases using CMDB
1. Change control of CI's
2. License Management
Lets say if there is one Software CI and have many relationship to desktop that will work for Desktop License Management but
When I look on a database CI's (Oracle instances on server, Sybase instances on server) and letís say for example we are running 100's of oracle instances on server CI. I also want to document each oracle instances which serves an application or services established in our company and can be individually changed. How companies handle this kind of situation?
this is what I am getting at regarding the CMDB not being able to do license management. I have sat through the same questions above in different organisations who were asking no more that you.
However when advised that to do this in any way that is the least bit accurate - it needs to be heavily automated. You can use specific tools to gather information on app installs etc and report it into a repositiry but if you want to link to the CMDB you just have to script / automate the relationship to the CMDB.
It is an easy task to ask on the outside but as you look into it it requires a lot of work and configurations.
Also if you sign up to deliver license management you have to get it 100% right - otherwise you can be wrong in you usage estimation and it could have the potential to cost you in penalties e.g if oracle rolls up - sweeps the network and finds out that you have more DB's in use that you have licenses for.
I agree this is a challenge. One place we are trying to control Changes on these CI's which require people input to CMDB through Change Process, people do make mistakes that is the reason we are using Discovery tools for Audit purpose which has its own challenges and on the other hand we are trying to including the license management.
We are also finding that it will be lot of work but we are very committed to get over this huge hump.
What I am looking help from the Experts is it advisable to go have individual CI's per oracle instance and have one CI for a Software like Microsoft Office 2000. The difference is that oracle instance to a server installed will be one to one relationship but for Microsoft Office 2000 and desktop installed it will be one to many relationship.
Joined: Sep 16, 2006 Posts: 3553 Location: London, UK
Posted: Fri May 30, 2008 10:09 pm Post subject:
You need to think of the following when dealing with SQL software
1 - You have the software installed on the server. This merely installs the necessary executable, libraies to run SQL on the server as well as the base tools to create databases
2 - You have the ability to create, destroy and modify user develoepd databases on the server which have the SQL software installed
The CMDB should treat #1 as a SOftware product that is tracked.
The real issue is how you want to track the development, creation, maintainance and destruction of the SQL database instances that are created on that server (farm) using the SQL db s/w as well as the risks / etc
If you create the DB as a CI, do you also create CIs for the Tables, Querys, forms, reports etc that are create w/in the database. How do you handle the adding/removing / reconfiguring of fields w/in the tables. - Do you expect DBA to submit RFC for that
You have to reach a happy medium for configuration and change mgmt.
Dont spend £10 to track a £ 0.02 item
Personally, I would create #1 as a software
Then I would develop a CI for 'Service' for the DB instances - which tracks the Service (DB) and the service users (licenses) and other services that use the Service (DB) _________________ John Hardesty
ITSM Manager's Certificate (Red Badge)
Change Management is POWER & CONTROL. /....evil laughter
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum